BOOK REVIEW:
A Light on the Hill: The Surprising Story of How a Local Church in the Nation’s Capital Influenced Evangelicalism by Caleb Morell. Crossway. 353 pages. 2025
****
You may not think that the history of a church would make for very interesting reading. However, after reading several positive reviews of the book, I decided to read Caleb Morell’s history of the 150-year-old Capitol Baptist Church (CHBS), which is located just blocks from the U.S Capitol in Washington D.C. My wife Tammy and I have had the pleasure of worshipping at CHBC while in Washington D.C. on a business trip.
Morell did an outstanding job researching the church’s history for this book. I very much enjoyed reading how God has used this church for nearly 150 years.
We are told that this is not the story of an extraordinary church. Rather, it is about God and how he delights to do extraordinary things through ordinary people and ordinary churches. The book looks at the factors and conditions that contribute to gospel faithfulness. The church has stayed centered on the gospel and present in the place God planted it because of the ordinary people who worked, prayed, sowed, and stayed.
Click on ‘Continue reading’ for:
BOOK REVIEWS ~ More of this review…
BOOK NEWS ~ Links to Interesting Articles
BOOK CLUB ~ Tim Keller on the Christian Life: The Transforming Power of the Gospel by Matt Smethurst
I’M CURRENTLY READING….
The origins of the church date back to between 1876 and 1878, when the Metropolitan Baptist Association began hosting a weekly prayer meeting on Wednesday evenings and, soon after that, a Sunday evening prayer service. On February 27, 1878, dozens gathered to form the Metropolitan Baptist Church. Joseph W. Parker would become the church’s first pastor.
As a matter of first importance, the church gave their attention to their governing documents: the statement of faith, church covenant, and rules of church order and discipline.
The church would survive a church split in 1884, when pastor Wilbur H. Ingersoll resigned and formed a rival church just two blocks away, taking thirty-three members with him. The author tells us that the story of Ingersoll and the church split of 1884 is a sobering reminder of how sin, pride, and factionalism can decimate a church community.
In 1885, William Henry Young would become pastor. The church would make the decision to adopt female deaconesses. Later, they would welcome a woman to preach from their pulpit. The author states that for twenty-first-century evangelicals, a woman preaching from the pulpit might be taken as an undisputable sign of theological liberalism. Surprisingly, however, this was not the case among many nominally conservative churches in the early twentieth century.
John Compton Ball would pastor the church for forty-one years. Sadly, Ball refused to cede pastoral leadership to K. Owen White, his successor. The author tells us that if ever there were a case study in how not to handle pastoral succession, this was it.
One significant difference between Ball’s ministry and White’s ministry was White’s commitment to expositional preaching. Sermons at Metropolitan had always been topical, focusing on a single verse during the Sunday morning service and a single verse during the evening service.
By 1948, well over a thousand packed into the church building every Sunday where there was standing room only at services. Beginning at Easter 1948, White led Metropolitan to adopt a two-service model for its Sunday morning services.
However, by 1961, Metropolitan’s membership was down to its lowest in twenty-one years. There was a downward spiral in membership experienced by Metropolitan Baptist Church in the 1960s and 1970s as the church fought to survive amid peace protests, racial unrest, rising crime, and members moving to the suburbs. The church would not admit it’s first Black member until 1955.
Sadly, pastor Harry Kilbride was guilty of serious sexual immorality. Mark Dever was called as pastor in 1993. In 1994, the church voted to drop “Metropolitan”, and became known as Capitol Hill Baptist Church.
The most significant change that Dever proposed in a new constitution was the recognition of a plurality of elders. From the church’s organization in 1878 until 1998, the church had always operated with a single pastor and a plurality of deacons. The entire process of devising and passing the constitution took over a year and ten months. it took nearly five years to revise the church membership, readopt the statement of faith and the church covenant, and introduce elders.
As membership steadily grew, the leadership had to make a decision regarding expanding the sanctuary, planting churches, going to a multi-site model, etc. They decided to plant churches. Today, many of CHBC’s church plants are planting their own churches.
From its earliest days, Capitol Hill Baptist Church understood itself to be a light on the Hill. Despite internal dissensions and the contextual challenges of being an urban church, Capitol Hill Baptist Church has remained centered on the gospel and rooted in its community for nearly 150 years.
The author looks at the preachers, members, and prayer as being key elements to the church being a light on the Hill. He summarizes them:
- The chief distinguishing mark of God’s kindness toward Capitol Hill Baptist Church has been the preachers who have heralded the gospel from its pulpit.
- Another distinguishing sign of God’s mercy has been the humble perseverance of saints like Celestia A. Ferris and Margaret Roy who lived hidden lives of quiet faithfulness.
- Finally, any good that has come from the ministry of Capitol Hill Baptist Church can ultimately be traced back to the power of prayer.
- Are We Post Woke? Tim Challies reviews Post Woke: Asserting a Biblical Vision of Race, Gender, and Sexuality by Neil Shenvi and Pat Sawyer. He writes “It is just the resource most people will need as they try to understand what it means to be woke, how society became this way, how they should think about it, and what they can do about it. Not only that, but it is just the book they will need to understand why the Bible offers better answers to the biggest questions.”
- Study, Savor and Share Scripture: Becoming What We Behold. My wife Tammy has published a book about HOW to study the Bible. The book is available on Amazon in both a Kindle and paperback edition. She writes “Maybe you have read the Bible but want to dig deeper and know God and know yourself better. Throughout the book I use the analogy of making a quilt to show how the Bible is telling one big story about what God is doing in the world through Christ. Quilting takes much patience and precision, just like studying the Bible, but the end result is well worth it.”
Won’t you read along with us?
Tim Keller on the Christian Life: The Transforming Power of the Gospel by Matt Smethurst
Pastor and author Timothy Keller (1950–2023) built a lasting legacy in Christian ministry, planting Redeemer Presbyterian Church and cofounding the Gospel Coalition. With sharp biblical insight that has shaped countless church leaders, along with counsel on the Christian life that has stirred and strengthened audiences worldwide, Keller’s teaching promises to influence generations to come.
Synthesizing Keller’s work topic by topic, each chapter of this book highlights a key aspect of the Christian life—covering his views on prayer, suffering, friendship, vocation, intimacy with God, and more. Written by pastor Matt Smethurst, Tim Keller on the Christian Life draws from Keller’s nearly 50 years of sermons, conference messages, and books to share practical theological insight that will galvanize leaders and laypeople alike.
As we read through this book, we now look at Chapter 7: Answering Heaven How Prayer Unlocks Intimacy with God. Here are a few helpful quotes from the chapter:
- One of the most vital takeaways from Keller’s teaching is this: Prayer, essentially, is answering God. He started the conversation—we did not. This means he sets the agenda and dictates the terms. Our voices are responding to his, not the other way around.
- Prayer, then, is equal parts response and gift—a response to revelation from God’s word and a gift for those secure in his grace.
- Spend some unhurried time reveling in who God is. If you begin there—contemplating his character, gazing at his glory, praising him for his promises—then your heart will be ready to bring requests to his throne.
- Prayer is awe, intimacy, struggle—yet the way to reality. There is nothing more important, or harder, or richer, or more life-altering. There is absolutely nothing so great as prayer.
- God will either give you what you ask for or give you what you would have asked for if you knew what he knows.
